The trouble I had with those All-Time Laker Team polls on
LATimes.com stems from the fact that they ask me to make cross-generation comparisons of great players from different eras. And admittedly, I feel qualified to speak to just one era, the 90s to the present. I mean, I do remember Showtime. But only through the eyes of a single digit ager and thus my opinions would be unbalanced. For example, my one memory of Mychal Thompson in his playing days was him missing a big free throw, hence I think he sucked. And as for the Jerry West Lakers...yeah I've heard of them.
Predictably, this led me to be somewhat biased toward the players that I've actually watched play. And I'm sure that most people felt this effect to a degree. But I guess that's the challenge. Another challenge would be to not take meaningless online polls so seriously.
With that in mind, here is a poll that I made up that takes the differing eras element out of the equation.
Free Online PollReal quick, here are some pro/cons for each guy:
Robert HorryPro - "Horry, for the win!" and the like, defended Webber-Sheed-Duncan during the title years, bad ass muthafucker
(throwing towel at Danny Ainge should not count since he wasn't on the Lakers when he did it)
Con - Showed up only for the playoffs, wildly inconsistent, the 0 for 39 shooting streak during the 2002-2003 playoffs
Now - on last legs with the Spurs, at least one big shot left in him, possible play-off foe
Rick FoxPro - The clamps he put down on Peja (and others), great entry passer, blocking out Duncan so that Kobe could put in the game winning put back in Game 3 (I think) of the 2001-2002 WC Semis against San Antonio, countless right hand lay-ups from the left side, tough as nails
Con - His hair, "Foxy", slow
Now - D-list actor, banging lots of chicks in L.A.
Derek FisherPro - Bull dog defender, high basketball IQ, has guns, 0.4, floor leader, dunked on Iverson in the 2001 Finals, taking charges both legit ones and flops, looked like Elvin from the Cosby Show
Con - Had trouble staying in front of certain guards (Bibby, Tony Parker, others), thought he could finish around the basket consistently (he couldn't), flopping/falling down while getting picked on a high pick and roll (that never gets called)
Now - Crafty veteran point guard on the Jazz, tutoring Deron Williams on big game dynamics, possible play-off foe
There you have it. Choose wisely for this decision will affect you for the rest of your life. That said, I hope Pat Riley doesn't sue me for using "Threepeat."